The Glen Eden Cycleway

By 8 Comments

This is my personal take on local interest in the Glen Eden Cycleway recently created on part of Captain Scott Road.

Cycleways have been in the news lately. They seem to provoke considerable dissent wherever they are implemented. If they are stand alone new infrastructure then opposition is muted. But Auckland in particular is so car centric in its design that any implementation of a cycleway at the cost of road space attracts criticism.

I can understand the concerns. There is the fear that ever worsening congestion will be made even worse by removal of space that cars have a monopoly over. That taking away car parks for whatever reason will mean that local town centre businesses will have fewer clients.

But there are three very strong counter arguments to these concerns:

  1. Getting people out of cars and walking or cycling will free up car space. Bikes take much less space. And some of them will catch the train meaning that the roads going into the city centre will be less clogged.
  2. Car parks destroy town centres. Instead of being places where people visit to spend time they visit, get out of their car, and then get back into their car as soon as possible. If you compare Titirangi with its recessed cafes and open spaces with outdoor dining to Glen Eden the variation is stark.
  3. When you build a road congestion initially improves but after a while the benefits are lost as people drive more in response to the extra capacity. As an example the North Western Motorway for a while provided a dramatic improvement in Auckland’s congestion. But now the benefits are hard to ascertain. The concept is known as induced demand. The international evidence supporting the concept and the futility of building more roads to address congestion is overwhelming.

This ABC video captures the phenomenon very well:

And coversely the opposite also happens. Taking away road capacity reduces demand for travel as people adjust.

There is an even stronger reason for Council to maximise the attractiveness of walking and cycling.

We are in the middle of a climate change emergency.

This is the potentially most devastating but most complex threat that our world faces.

It will not be solved overnight.  To deal with it will require a sustained effort over decades.

And transport is a major contributor to greenhouse gas emissions.  If we want to meet country and regional goals of being carbon neutral in the future we have to act now.

The big PT projects are important. But they are expensive and they take a long time.

As an example double tracking and electrification of the western line started in 2001 but was only completed in 2015.

City Rail link which is absolutely vital for the city started in 2016 and should be complete by 2024.

Transport is a major contributor to greenhouse gas emissions and if we are going to meet our goal of New Zealand being climate neutral by 2050 then we are going to have to make some rather radical changes to the way that we live.

This is why walking and cycling are so important.

The local board as its contribution has formulated our Greenways Plan, designed to complete a walking and cycling network in our rohe. We believe that we can make a real difference by promoting local projects that improve on existing discrete walking and cycling infrastructure.

There is an existing cycleway through part of Glen Eden built as part of Project Twin Streams. You can cycle from the southern border of Ceramco Park to past the carpark and then through to the back of Savoy Road. The cycleway is of high quality and very pleasant. But it does not go very far. The cycleway is in the map below.

We had discussed with Glenora League the possibility of a bridge from the end of the cycleway over to their land and for the cycleway to then continue through Harold Moody Reserve but they were concerned about the implications for parking and safety and declined our suggestion.

So the temporary cycleway on Captain Scott Road was the best alternative. It is temporary at this stage and its benefits will be reviewed.

The desire is to make it safe for cyclists. The advice we had was that it needed to be placed on both sides of the road and that parking would have to be stopped for the affected part of the road.

The intent is to improve safety for cyclists getting into Glen Eden. Eventually we want to create another cycleway to Sunnyvale from Glen Eden, and once the Te Whau Pathway is completed we would want a safe link completed to there.

Auckland has lots of good quality and safe small cycleways. To make them functional they have to be joined up. This is why projects such as Captain Scott Road are important.

There is disruption occurring. An estimated 60 car parks have been removed. They have not been lost, people can still park in adjoining roads, They will have to walk further. Some car parks will no longer be required in and around the town centre as people take up biking instead of driving.

But we have to improve our cycling infrastructure. As David Slack described the situation in his blog More than a Fielding (paywalled):

We aren’t clamouring for bikes because we want to enhance our leafy suburbs and it goes with our lattes, we’re doing it because there needs to be huge change in the way we get around. We can’t go on filling the atmosphere with emissions. For many of our trips we could be getting out of cars and onto bikes, and that’s what needs to happen. 

And we can’t do it while people are scared of cars that monster them and sometimes knock them down and sometimes kill them.  

Bikes are not some quirky oddball novelty, no matter how many mediocre Heathers and Mikes and Stevens still see things that way. 

People are finding to their delight that riding a bike is a quicker, easier, more comfortable way to make many of your trips. 

If we just give them space they will make many more of their trips on a bike the same way people have in city after city that has already seen sense and switched to a better future.

The test is to see if we can reduce congestion, improve the attractiveness of Glen Eden, make it safer for cyclists and make the Greenways network more complete and more attractive. And take further steps that need to be taken now if we are going to avoid the worst excesses of climate change.

I am confident that we will be able to meet at least some of these goals. And I am convinced that for the sake of our community, particularly the young that will face the ravages of climate change if we do not address it adequately, we have to try our best.




  1. Rose Williams says:

    Sadly, I don’t think the changes have enhanced Glen Eden at all…whilst training at the gym, sometimes until 7:30/8:00pm, the traffic congestion is still hideous, not as bad as during the so-called upgrade, but still pretty bad. With all the massively reduced parking spaces, where do you think the people who work-in and service the Glenmall commercial area are going to park? The people who catch the train take many of these spaces early in the a.m. I feel really sorry for the businesses in Glenmall, not only have they been financially impacted by the various COVID Lockdowns, but now by all the upheaval of the road works/closures and much of the feedback that I’ve read and heard about how people feel about it going forward, they are saying that the congestion that has now been caused, it’s just too hard and they won’t bother going anywhere near Glen Eden. I’ve been working in Glenmall for the last 8 years, I may have seen a mere handful of people riding bikes around the area in this whole time. Many of us have busy lives, working full time, with families to care for, extended family members to support and with many other commitments that we have to fit into our time-restricted days, which makes public transport an impractical option and that’s not even taking into consideration the inefficient public transport system that we have. I think a little more thought and some good options put in place first would have been more prudent.

    1. Greg Presland says:

      Thanks for your comment Rose. To respond to the points made:

      1. I have had an office in the area for the past 33 years and have worked full time in that time. I am aware the problems that the area has. it is a great area but it really does need improvement.
      2. I agree not many people cycle in the area. There is a lot of potential. In other parts of Auckland and in the world providing safe cycle infrastructure has sparked use.
      3. Public transport is improving. The rail system is way better than it was in the past. I agree it does not suit everyone and is not an option for everyone but every time someone uses the train and does not drive it decreases congestion for everyone else.

  2. Rose Williams says:

    Greg, I grew up in Candia Road, Swanson when it was still gravel, no footpaths or street lights and we were zoned rural -:RD1 Henderson, I walked to primary school – 1 mile each way and caught the bus to Henderson High School…. fast-forward to the early 80’s, I lived in Karapiti Place – border of Glen Eden/Titirangi, access via Glen Eden – I shopped at 3 Guys in Glenmall (Gubays), I was also a road cyclist/motorcyclist/car driver and business owner in Henderson & Mt Eden at the time….I’ve lived in Rotorua & Awakeri/Whakatane….worked on cruise ships for approx 7 years, so I class myself as intetnationally aware/experienced…. nowhere, anywhere in the world have I seen such an abomination as I’ve seen in Captain Scott Road – even in traffic-jammed London, St Petersburg, New York, Mexico etc. etc. etc …however, I notice tonight that some of the strips have vanished from the corner of Savoy & Captain Scott Road – thank goodness for that, my Subaru Outback doesn’t like those tight corners, it was dangerous….I like the new pedestrian humps & roundabouts in Glen Eden, but those white sticks and theft of parking spaces are so wrong on so many levels….not seen one cyclist in G’Mall in the last 2 weeks

    1. Greg Presland says:

      Greetings Rose

      It is a pop up. If it is going to be made permanent it will look dramatically different.

      I saw three cyclists last night about 6 pm as I was making my way home.

      This is the worst time for cycling. I suspect that spring will show a significant increase.

  3. Rose Williams says:

    Everyone I know who has experienced this, hopes the pop-up, pops-off sooner rather than later…

  4. Kevin O'Carroll says:

    If you really think this is going to increase the number of cyclists in and around Glen Eden, you are living in a dream world. In the meantime, you have upset a lot of people. I am someone directly affected as I live on the part of Captain Scott Rd where the cycleway has been installed. I absolutely resent that my family have to park and walk hundred of meters when they visit because of the limited off-road parking on my property. This includes my 86 year old mother-in-law. It becomes even more of a problem at night given the safety issues. I personally will be actively campaigning against Future West as a result of this ill-conceived plan

    1. Greg Presland says:

      That is your prerogative Kevin. Sometimes we have to make decisions that affect all of the local communities and quite often there will be instances where individuals are adversely affected. For me my motivation is the world that my granddaughter is going to grow up in. There may be some disruption as we change our community to one that emits less carbon and is more sustainable but I don’t see there is any alternative.

      If you are going to post stuff on Facebook do you want to tag me in just so that I can respond?

  5. Oliver Barrett says:

    Very disappointing that discussions with Glenora League were unsuccessful. Building a bridge here would be a great step to linking up Ceramco Park and Harold Moody Reserve, Duck Park and the Tennis Club and encouraging a large catchment area to walk / cycle for recreation, to reach their sports club or in the other direction to reach the Glen Eden Intermediate / Kauriland Primary Schools. Next step would be to link Duck Park up with Oates Road to link with Town Centre and Railway Station.
    Did I not read that Glenora League lease the land off Auckland Council! Can it not be made part of any future lease that some land be given over to a footpath. Does it not link to their ethos of encouraging activity and by encouraging walking and cycling they would need less car park spaces for their local club useage!

Leave a Comment